Hello dear
Welcome to Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe
Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe, located in Atlantic Beach, FL, is a cozy, family-owned bakery that offers a wide variety of delicious pies. With a focus on quality and homemade taste, Pie Heaven prides itself on its flaky crusts and flavorful fillings. Customers rave about the friendly staff, including the owner, who go above and beyond to provide exceptional service. The chicken pot pie and chocolate bourbon pecan pie are customer favorites, showcasing the bakery's commitment to high-quality ingredients and traditional baking methods. The quaint atmosphere and charitable contributions make Pie Heaven a must-visit for pie lovers looking for a truly authentic and satisfying dessert experience.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe
Welcome to Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe, a charming bakery located in Atlantic Beach, FL. This family-owned establishment has been serving up delicious pies and desserts for years, earning the title of the best pie in the Jacksonville area.
With a focus on quality and warmth, Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe offers a wide variety of pies by the slice or as full pies, along with adorable 6-inch pie options. From classic flavors like chocolate cream to unique creations like chocolate bourbon pecan, there is something to satisfy every sweet tooth.
Customer reviews rave about the friendly staff, who are passionate about their pies and eager to share their knowledge with customers. The cozy atmosphere adds to the experience, making you feel like you're enjoying dessert in Grandma's kitchen.
Not only do they excel in taste, but Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe also supports charities, giving you a feel-good reason to indulge in their delectable treats. Whether you're craving a comforting chicken pot pie or a decadent dessert, Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe is sure to delight your taste buds.
For a slice of pie heaven, visit Pie Heaven Bakery Cafe and treat yourself to a memorable culinary experience.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great pie & very friendly staff. Best pie we found in the Jacksonville area. We'll be back! ”
“ Ohhh the food is so good, I love pie so maybe I'm biased but wow. The service was amazing think she was the owner but little old lady so nice and thoughtful telling me about all their pies and such. Building was a little old but just what you'd expect for a family owned spot that been there for years. ”
“ What an adorable little shop! With the sweetest staff members! They had pies by the slice as well as full pies and little 6 inch pies! I was craving a chocolate cream one so I went with the 6 inch Triple chocolate cream pie so I could bring it home to share with my husband! It had a lot of chocolate cream flavor and I loved the pie crust! Perfect dessert! Can't wait to try more in the future! ”
“ Lovely little shop making great pies! Very happy with the chicken pot pie; it's clear why it's a best seller. The chocolate bourbon pecan pie was fantastic as well. Great, flaky crust! ”
“ As you walk around the grocery store a lot of products say 'homemade' on them. Of course they are light years away from being homemade. As long time pie makers we can testify that Pie Heaven pies are about as close to homemade as you will ever find outside your own kitchen, and for those not familiar with the intricacies and mysteries of pie crust Pie Heaven pies are probably a lot better than 'homemade'. We have never been disappointed with a pie from Pie Heaven, and part of your enjoyment is knowing that you not only got to eat a great pie but you contributed to worthwhile charities. The folks at Pie Heaven are friendly, funny and committed to making great pies and to service. Pie Heaven is located in a small wooden building that looks like someone's home, and eating there is like eating in Grandma's kitchen. ”
“ This is one of the best places in Mayport/Jacksonville to buy a pie, quiche or other. The small pies already made up are $7.00 and it goes up to quiche and pies up to $39.00. Why so much? Because they only bake with the finest and best ingredients. Pros-great baked items and staff. Cons:parking is small Order your holiday pies early! ”
“ I've driven past this tooo many time to have never stopped in. I'm so glad I finally did bc I was soooooo satisfied with all my treats! Ordered a slice of margarita key lime and triple berry. A small 6in lemon meringue and key lime and everything was fresh and flavorful. The slices are plenty big and their selections are amazing! Everyone working was professional, inviting, and friendly! Can't wait to come and try more!! Thank you for a first great experience! ”
“ I have heard from word of mouth I need to get here but just never seemed to be in the area until recently. I stopped by on a Friday evening and picked up some pies for 2 events the next day. My first was the Chicken pot pie. It was huge and weighty. We warmed it up in the oven as instructions stated until the homemade crust was browning and when it was cut you could see it was a truly a filled pie. It contained a gravy with vegetables like peas and organic chicken. It was delicious. My second choice was a coconut custard for my friends birthday and it was sooooo good, I may need to drive back a hour and get another soon. mmmmm Lots of choices and worth the stop.Look for the blue building! ”
“ OMGawd! The smells rolling out the door overwhelm your senses! You want one of everything! Hahaha! Although, that could be expensive! This is their 8th anniversary and awesome incentives all week! I stopped in today for two chicken pot pies, along with a Quiche and a Coconut Custard for dessert! I have frozen the quiche for later and one of the chicken pot pies is going to a sick friend ... but this one is all mine! Filled with organic veggies and chunks of chicken - this is a fabulous meal! Run, don't walk to this cute little bldg along Mayport Rd. ”
